APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

How I approach the work

A look at the actual reasoning: observations, competing explanations, organizational relationships and the next decision.

01 / APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

Before prescribing, find out what the problem is

A management problem often arrives already explained: “The departments don't cooperate.” “She is too pushy.” “Our people resist change.” “We need another reporting procedure.” Sometimes the explanation is right. Sometimes it is the most convenient story in the room.

I separate what we observed from what we inferred. Then I examine the people, their relationships, the organization's design, and the consequences of the current arrangements. The goal is the one explanation that survives contact with evidence and leads to a decision.

02 / APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

A small example: two departments, one recurring fight

Consider this example. Two department heads keep blaming each other for late deliveries. The obvious response is to send them to a communication workshop.

That might help. But first, I'd ask what is actually happening and distinguish at least three possibilities drawn from my writing on organizational conflict:

  • Embedded friction: The departments are measured against targets that make cooperation expensive. One wins when the other loses.
  • Politics friction: Influence, status or a competition for resources has become more valuable than solving the customer problem.
  • Interface friction: People misread one another, defend territory, or communicate badly even when the formal design is adequate.

One situation can involve all three. To distinguish them, we would examine actual decisions, handovers, targets, sources of information and the sequence of interactions. The answer might involve a conversation, changed decision authority, different measures, or some combination.

The difference: We stop treating the word “conflict” as a diagnosis and start investigating the mechanism producing it.

This example adapts distinctions from my original article (Un)Resolved Conflicts, Business Perspective.

03 / APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

The tools behind the investigation

Taxonomy helps us classify subjects: strategy, processes, people, control, knowledge, culture. Ontology is the investigation of their meaning and relationships: how these parts influence each other in this particular organization.

When the two departments argue about late deliveries, we can also trace the consequences through the four Ps: Profitability, Products, Processes and People. A decision that improves one measure may impose a cost on the others. That connection matters more than memorizing a framework.

04 / APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

From As Is to To Be

  1. Describe the current condition. What happened, where, how often and with what effect?
  2. Test more than one explanation. What evidence would distinguish between the hypotheses?
  3. Choose an intervention. A decision, conversation, experiment, change of responsibility or organizational redesign.
  4. Watch what follows. Did the change address the problem? What else did it affect?
  5. Keep the useful learning. Update the plan, the organization or the individual's personal development dossier.

The findings should lead to a decision, an experiment or a change in how the organization works.

WHAT YOUR DOSSIER COULD CONTAIN

Your Personal Development Dossier.

In an extended mentoring engagement, you and I may build a working record of the situation, your objectives, decisions, experiments and evidence of change. The format depends on your needs; it is not a standard personality report.

See an illustrative dossier page →
PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT DOSSIERILLUSTRATIVE STRUCTURE
As Is

What is happening; which observations and assumptions matter.

To Be

What would count as useful change, and why.

Work in progress

Decisions, conversations, practices, evidence and revisions.

A place to begin

What are you dealing with?

It may be a decision, an organizational problem, or a situation you cannot yet explain well. A few sentences are enough to start.

Discuss your situation