<Any resemblance to actual persons or actual events is purely intentional>
I heard that sentence recently about a mentee of mine.
OK, I might be emotionally protective as a “mommy bear” but that’s not what pisses me off.
Maybe she is pushy.
Maybe she isn’t.
But here’s my problem:
“Pushy” is not a serious managerial analysis.
It’s a label.
When you don’t know what to say, so you think you said something smart.
But you didn’t.
For decades, in the US, we used a similar one.
“He is not a team player.”
Same intellectual laziness.
Same character assassination.
When we say someone is pushy, what are we actually saying?
Nothing, that’s correct.
Nothing at all.
Except that we lack leadership competence.
If you can’t map ‘pushiness’ to concrete situations, to real moments where there was at least one objective; some real constraints; some available alternatives; and most important, some trade-offs that had to be made…
…then you’re not evaluating behavior.
You’re telling a lame story from your cozy perspective.
“I feel that…”
Here I draw a hard line.
Calling someone “pushy” is not leadership.
It is character assassination by lazy leaderless labelship.
Leaders are not allowed to hide behind labels, because labels erase context, intention, constraints, and responsibility for trade-offs.
The moment managers reduce one’s behavior to a dichotomy pushy vs. not pushy, they abandon deep thinking and replace it with shallow judgment.
Real leadership does not work with generalized adjectives.
No, it works with:
- Descriptions
- Continuums
- Trade-offs
- Consequences
“She is pushy” is taxonomy. Placing people into boxes. Wrong.
It should be ontology. Understanding what actually happened in real situations with real outcomes and costs.
If you manage people through labels, you are not developing either yourself or other leaders. You are selecting for compliance and calling it culture.
The hard part of ‘pushiness’ is that this behavior is not static.
At the same time, it can mean GSD, moving forward, meeting deadlines but also stepping on people’s emotions, trust, and engagement.
Since reality is not linear and leadership definitely isn’t also…
That’s why throwing labels like used paper tissues is a big no-no.
So, the next time you get tempted to call someone pushy or not a team player or whatever take a break.
Measure twice, cut once.
Are you describing situational behavior or just throwing labels?
Because labels feel safe.
Context is demanding.
And leadership decisions made without context are not wise.
Just convenient.