← All essays

Leading People · Essay

Toxic Positivity

Chupacabra of Corporate Dark Forests

The one definition of toxic positivity would be the compulsive pressure to be optimistic at all costs even when reality is having a nervous breakdown.

As experts may say, “the excessive over-generalization of optimism that dismisses real emotions.”

Good. Clear. Useful.
Let’s now step into business reality.

Because in companies, toxic positivity can quickly become the Chupacabra.

Some swear it’s everywhere.
Some blame it for everything.
And some use it like a legal defense the moment they’re asked to stretch, grow, or deliver.

To keep it simple, in every business there are two kinds of people.

  1. The “This can’t be done” people.

The moment a challenge appears, they hit the brakes, grab the rulebook, and say:
“No, impossible. No way.”
And when you encourage them to keep pushing, suddenly…
“Ah! Toxic positivity! You’re forcing optimism!”
No, my friends. We’re forcing duty, effort, and thinking. Positive thinking.

  1. The “Maybe it can’t be done, but we’ll see what happens” people.

They’re not delusional.
They don’t pretend everything is fine.
But they will search, question, learn, test, fail and fall, and get up again.
These are the people who built everything we admire in business.
Every big thing was once a thought, then a vision, followed by hard work, followed by failure, followed by another attempt.
That’s not positivity. That’s a belief in our own resourcefulness.

Yes, I agree, toxic positivity is real.
Yes, it’s dangerous.

But what if the fear of Chupacabra is worse than the actual creature.

What if remedy is worse that the disease.

It is so easy to go from “don’t suppress emotions” to “any expectation is psychological oppression.”

Work hours are not group therapy hours.
If one person is allowed to turn every difficulty into a team-wide emotional excavation, then everyone has the right to do the same.
That’s not culture.
That’s Pandora’s box.

Companies exist to solve client problems.
Clients pay you for your stability, clarity, resilience, and execution.

Not for your inner turbulence.

Yes, people in companies are entitled to their feelings.
They are not entitled to use those feelings as a reason to stop contributing.

Psychological safety means “I can say the hard truth” not “I never have to feel challenged.”

Great things require risk, failure, tension, and trying again.
Always have. Always will.

The opposite of toxic positivity can’t be “anything difficult is trauma; don’t tell me it’s gonna be fine.”
It must be taking responsibility for our states, grown-up resilience, and the courage to do our part.

In her companion post, psychologist @Nikunja Gujar is going to “kick my butt” … as she probably should.

Fran MikuličićReturn to the Thinking Library →